Free resource
The COA red-flag checklist.
Twelve things to check on a supplier’s certificate of analysis before you order, and the question to send the supplier for each. All twelve are below. Want it as a one-page printable PDF? Leave your email.
The 12 red flags
- 01 Method
An assay figure with no method, or a method that cannot measure what the label claims (for example total polysaccharide by phenol-sulfuric acid offered as β-glucan).
Ask the supplier: “Which method produced this figure, and does it measure the compound named on the label?”
- 02 Method
No figure for the likely adulterant or diluent (for mushroom extracts: no α-glucan or starch result).
Ask the supplier: “Please send the α-glucan or starch result for this lot.”
- 03 Identity
Plant or fungal part not stated, or identity reported as “conforms” with no method or reference material.
Ask the supplier: “Which part was used, and how was identity tested? Please send the method and reference material.”
- 04 Traceability
No lot or batch number, or a lot number that does not match the shipment or the label.
Ask the supplier: “Which lot does this COA cover? Please confirm it matches our shipment.”
- 05 Traceability
The same layout, wording and results across different lots or dates.
Ask the supplier: “Please send COAs for the last three production lots.”
- 06 Laboratory
Tested only by the factory’s own QC lab, or by a lab whose ISO/IEC 17025 scope does not cover that test.
Ask the supplier: “Which lab ran each test? Please send its accreditation number and scope.”
- 07 Contaminants
No numeric heavy-metal results for lead, cadmium, arsenic and mercury.
Ask the supplier: “Please send numeric Pb, Cd, As and Hg results with the method used.”
- 08 Contaminants
No microbiology, or only total plate count with no pathogen tests.
Ask the supplier: “Please send pathogen results for this lot, not only total plate count.”
- 09 Contaminants
No pesticide screen, or “conforms” with no list of residues, method or limit of quantification.
Ask the supplier: “Which residues were screened, by which method, at what limit of quantification?”
- 10 Consistency
Dates that do not add up: test date before manufacture date, report issued before sampling, expiry that does not fit the stability data.
Ask the supplier: “Please confirm the manufacture, sampling, test and report dates for this lot.”
- 11 Consistency
Extract ratio, carrier and assay that cannot all be true at once.
Ask the supplier: “Please confirm the extract ratio, the carrier and its percentage.”
- 12 Supporting documents
Certificates referenced on the COA (organic, GMP, ISO) that are missing, expired, or issued to a different company or site.
Ask the supplier: “Please send each certificate named on the COA, with issuer, scope and expiry.”
Rather we check it for you?
Send us your COA. Within 24 hours we reply with the top 2 red flags we see, free.
Get a free 24-hour flag checkGet the printable PDF
All 12 flags on one page, with a column to mark each line pass, query or flag. We email it to you and show the download link straight away.