Our standards
How we check a supplier.
The same careful method on every document and every factory, written down so you know exactly what you are paying for.
01 Principles
Five rules we read by.
- 01
A claim is only as good as its method.
We read the method before the number. A result from a method that cannot measure the claimed compound is not evidence for that claim.
- 02
A lab is only accredited for what is on its scope.
ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation applies to listed tests [1]. We check the scope for each test, not the logo on the letterhead.
- 03
One lot proves one lot.
We ask for several consecutive lots and compare them. Real results vary. Identical results across lots are a question.
- 04
Absence is a finding.
A parameter that is missing from the COA is reported as missing, not ignored.
- 05
Uncertainty is stated, not smoothed.
Where the evidence is incomplete, the finding is “query”, with the exact information needed to resolve it.
02 What we check
Applied to every document.
| Check | What it covers |
|---|---|
| Method | Named, appropriate to the analyte and the matrix, and specific enough to support the claim. |
| Laboratory | Identity of the lab, independence from the factory, and accreditation scope for each test [1][2][3]. |
| Lot and dates | Lot number matches the shipment; manufacture, sampling, test and report dates are consistent. |
| Completeness | Identity, assay, heavy metals, pesticide residues, microbiology and residual solvents as relevant. |
| Results | Numeric values with units, limits and limits of quantification. |
| Internal consistency | Extract ratio, carrier, assay and part used agree across COA, spec sheet and flow chart. |
| Provenance | Signs of recycled templates or edits; report numbers verified with issuing labs where possible. |
| Supplier identity | Business licence and scope checked against the national enterprise registry [4]. |
For US brands, this work supports, but does not replace, your own supplier qualification. Relying on a supplier’s COA requires qualifying the supplier, including confirming the COA’s results through your own testing or examination [5].
03 How findings are marked
Four marks. Shape carries the meaning.
- Pass
- Supported by a suitable method, a numeric result and a lab whose scope covers the test.
- Query
- Possibly fine, but the evidence is incomplete. We state what is needed.
- Flag
- The line does not support the claim, or contradicts other documents. Do not order on it.
- Missing
- A parameter your markets or specification require is absent.
In examples, a small dot marks a data point we verified against an outside source, such as a lab’s accreditation scope.
Sources
- [1] ISO/IEC 17025:2017, General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. www.iso.org/standard/66912.html
- [2] International Laboratory Accreditation Cooperation. ILAC MRA and signatories. ilac.org/ilac-mra-and-signatories/
- [3] China National Accreditation Service for Conformity Assessment (CNAS). www.cnas.org.cn/
- [4] National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System, State Administration for Market Regulation of China. www.gsxt.gov.cn/
- [5] US Code of Federal Regulations, 21 CFR 111.75. www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-111/subpart-E/section-111.75
Next step
Send us your COA. Get the top 2 red flags in 24 hours.
Free, and no call needed. Email us your supplier’s COA and within 24 hours we reply with the 2 biggest red flags we see. Need a new supplier instead? Send us a sourcing brief.