How to find a reliable supplement manufacturer in China: 20 questions to ask
Twenty questions that separate a real supplement ingredient factory from a well-presented trader, before you send the deposit.
Verilyth Team 5 min read
In short
- Start by confirming who you are dealing with: look up the company’s unified social credit code on China’s national enterprise registry and check its business scope includes manufacturing.
- Ask for the plant’s own licence, three lots of COAs, a live video walk-through and permission for independent lab testing.
- Real factories answer quickly with documents; vague answers, screenshots and pressure to pay first are the warning signs.
The first purchase order is the cheapest moment to ask hard questions. Before the deposit, the supplier wants your business and you can walk away. After it, every question costs leverage.
This is the list we work through with a Chinese ingredient supplier before a brand commits. It is organised in five groups. Not every question applies to every ingredient, but every group does.
A note on tone: none of these questions are hostile. Good factories answer them routinely, often faster than you expect. The ones that stall are telling you something.
1. Who are you, legally?
The first job is to establish who you are dealing with: a manufacturer, a trading company, or a manufacturer that also trades other people’s products.
1. What is the full registered company name, and the unified social credit code? Every Chinese company has an 18-character unified social credit code on its business licence. With the name and code you can look the company up on the National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System, which shows registration status, registered capital, legal representative and business scope1.
2. Does the business scope include manufacturing this product? A trader’s scope typically covers sales, import and export. A manufacturer’s scope should include production of the relevant product. Neither is wrong, but you should know which one you are paying.
3. Is the production site at the registered address? If not, which entity owns the site? Many groups register the sales company in a city and the plant in a county. Ask for the plant’s own licence and check the names connect.
4. Which licences and certificates does the production site hold, and who issued them? Ask for copies, then check that the company name, address and product scope on each certificate match the site you are buying from, and that they are in date.
2. What exactly will you ship?
5. Can you send the specification sheet, with the test method named for every parameter? A specification without methods cannot be compared with another supplier’s. See how to read a supplement COA.
6. What is the raw material, where is it grown or made, and by whom? For botanicals and mushrooms: species, part used, growing substrate, region. For fermentation or synthesis: organism or route, starting materials, solvents.
7. Can you send the process flow chart, from raw material to packed powder? The flow chart tells you which contaminants to test for. An ethanol extraction needs a residual solvent result. A carrier needs a percentage on the spec.
8. What carrier or excipient is added, at what percentage? Carriers are normal. Undisclosed carriers are not. The percentage should be consistent with the extract ratio and the assay.
3. How do you know it meets the spec?
9. Which tests are done in-house, and which by an external lab? Both are normal. You need to know which lines on the COA are independent.
10. Which external labs do you use, and what are their accreditation numbers? ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation applies to specific tests2. In China, labs are accredited by CNAS, which publishes a searchable directory3. Check the scope covers the tests on your COA.
11. Can you send COAs for the last three production lots? Three lots show variation. Identical results across lots are a reason to ask more questions.
12. For this lot, can you send the raw data behind the assay? For HPLC, the chromatogram. For enzymatic assays, the total, α- and β-glucan figures. A good QC team will have them.
13. Will you accept testing of a production-lot sample by an independent lab of our choosing? This is the single most useful question. A confident factory says yes and asks which lab.
4. Can you show us?
14. Can we do a live video walk-through of the production line this week? A live call, not a recorded video. Ask to see raw material storage, extraction, concentration, drying, packing and the QC lab, and ask to see the lot you are buying if it exists yet.
15. Can the sample come from a production lot, with the lot number on the bag? A showroom sample shows what the factory can make on a good day. A production-lot sample shows what it does make.
16. Do you keep retained samples for each lot, and for how long? Retained samples let a dispute be settled by testing rather than argument.
5. What happens after the first order?
17. Will you notify us in writing before changing raw material source, process, site or lab? Change notification is the cheapest protection a brand can ask for. Put it in the purchase agreement.
18. What is your lead time, and how does it change around Chinese New Year? Most factories slow down or stop for a period around the holiday. Plan orders and testing time around it.
19. Who is the named QC contact, and how quickly do they answer technical questions? You want a person, not only a sales account. Ask a technical question early and time the answer.
20. Is anyone else being paid on this order? If an agent or intermediary is involved, you should know. Our own rule is that any fee we receive from a factory is disclosed to the brand in writing before the order.
How to read the answers
Score the answers on two things: speed and specificity. A real factory with a working QC function answers most of these within a day or two, with documents rather than descriptions. Vague answers, documents that arrive as screenshots, refusals to allow independent testing, and pressure to pay before questions are answered are the patterns that matter.
For US brands, this work also feeds into supplier qualification. Under 21 CFR 111.75, relying on a supplier’s COA requires you to qualify the supplier, including confirming the COA’s results through your own testing or examination4. The questions above are the groundwork for that.
If you would rather hand the list to someone who reads the answers for a living, that is our factory vetting service. You can also request a sourcing brief with what you already have.
Footnotes
-
National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System (国家企业信用信息公示系统), State Administration for Market Regulation of China. https://www.gsxt.gov.cn/ ↩
-
ISO/IEC 17025:2017, General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. https://www.iso.org/standard/66912.html ↩
-
China National Accreditation Service for Conformity Assessment (CNAS). https://www.cnas.org.cn/ ↩
-
US Code of Federal Regulations, 21 CFR 111.75, What must you do to determine whether specifications are met? https://www.ecfr.gov/current/title-21/chapter-I/subchapter-B/part-111/subpart-E/section-111.75 ↩
Common questions
How can I check if a Chinese supplier is a real factory?
Ask for the full company name and unified social credit code, then look it up on China’s National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System. A manufacturer’s business scope should include production of the product, not only sales and trade.
What documents should a supplement ingredient manufacturer send?
Its business licence, the production site’s own licence, a specification sheet, COAs for three recent lots, and any certificates it claims (GMP, ISO, organic) with their scope and expiry dates.
Is a video factory tour enough?
A live video walk-through is a good first check of the raw material store, production line and QC lab. For large orders, an in-person visit and independent lab testing of a production lot give more certainty.
What are the warning signs when vetting a Chinese supplier?
Slow or vague answers, documents sent only as screenshots, refusal to allow independent lab testing, and pressure to pay before your questions are answered.
- factory vetting
- China
- supplier qualification
- documents