Lion’s mane beta-glucan vs polysaccharides: what the percentage really means
Two lion’s mane extracts can both claim 30% and contain very different material. Why beta-glucan beats polysaccharides, and what to ask your supplier.
Verilyth Team 4 min read
In short
- “30% polysaccharides” and “30% beta-glucan” are different measurements, and the first can be mostly starch.
- Specify lion’s mane by beta-glucan measured with an enzymatic method (total glucan minus alpha-glucan).
- Ask for three lots and check that the lab’s accreditation covers the glucan test.
If you buy lion’s mane extract on its headline percentage, you are comparing numbers that may not measure the same thing. One supplier’s “30% polysaccharides” and another’s “30% β-glucan” can describe very different materials. Even two “30% β-glucan” offers can differ, depending on how the figure was produced.
This post explains why, in plain terms, and what to ask for instead.
What you are actually trying to measure
Mushroom fruiting bodies and mycelium contain β-glucans, polysaccharides built from glucose with β-linkages. In fungi these are mainly 1,3:1,6-β-glucans1. They are part of the fungal cell wall and are the compounds most brands mean when they specify a mushroom extract by glucan content.
The problem is that glucose-based polysaccharides are not unique to fungi. Starch, from the grain a mycelium was grown on or from added carriers such as maltodextrin, is also a glucose polymer, with α-linkages. A useful method has to tell the two apart.
Method 1: phenol-sulfuric acid, reported as “polysaccharides”
The phenol-sulfuric acid method was published in 1956 as a general colorimetric method for sugars and related substances2. Concentrated acid breaks polysaccharides down, the products react with phenol, and the colour is read on a spectrophotometer.
It is quick and cheap, and it is still widely used for “total polysaccharide” figures on mushroom COAs. But it responds to carbohydrates broadly. It does not distinguish fungal β-glucan from starch, maltodextrin or other sugars in the sample.
So a lion’s mane extract reported as “Polysaccharides ≥30% (UV)” may be telling you about the extract, or about the grain and carrier in it. The number alone cannot tell you which.
Method 2: enzymatic total glucan minus α-glucan
McCleary and Draga published a method in 2016 designed for exactly this problem1. In outline:
- Total glucan. The sample is hydrolysed with acid to release glucose from all glucans, and the glucose is measured specifically using an enzymatic reagent.
- α-Glucan. In a separate portion, starch and glycogen are hydrolysed with enzymes that act only on α-linkages, and the glucose released is measured.
- β-Glucan. β-Glucan is calculated as total glucan minus α-glucan.
Because both steps measure glucose specifically, sugars that are not glucose do not inflate the result. Because α-glucan is measured and subtracted, starch is not counted as β-glucan. The method is available as a commercial assay kit, which makes it practical for contract labs to run.
The same study tested commercial products. Products made from mycelium grown on grain contained mostly starch, and their β-glucan content was low, in many cases below 1% w/w1.
Why the method matters more than the number
Put the two methods side by side and the problem is clear.
| Question | Phenol-sulfuric “polysaccharides” | Enzymatic β-glucan |
|---|---|---|
| Counts fungal β-glucan | Yes | Yes |
| Counts starch from grain or carrier | Yes | No, measured separately |
| Counts other sugars | Yes | No |
| Reports α-glucan | No | Yes |
| Tells fruiting body from mycelium on grain | No | Indirectly, through the α-glucan figure |
A 30% phenol-sulfuric figure is compatible with a good fruiting-body extract. It is also compatible with a starch-heavy product. A 30% enzymatic β-glucan figure, with a low α-glucan figure on the same lot, narrows the possibilities a great deal.
What to ask a supplier for
When a lion’s mane supplier quotes a percentage, ask four things.
1. Which method produced this number? If the answer is “polysaccharides”, “UV” or “in-house”, the number is not a β-glucan figure. Ask whether they have enzymatic results.
2. What is the α-glucan or starch figure on the same lot? An enzymatic β-glucan result should come with total glucan and α-glucan. If only the β-glucan line is reported, ask for the other two.
3. Which lab ran it, and is the test on its accreditation scope? ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation applies to specific tests3. Check that the scope covers the glucan assay, not only heavy metals or microbiology.
4. Is it fruiting body or mycelium, and grown on what? The method tells you about glucans. It does not replace a clear part-used statement and a production record. Ask for both, and for identity testing against an authenticated reference.
What the method does not tell you
An enzymatic β-glucan figure is a good start, not a full specification. It says nothing about heavy metals, pesticide residues, microbiology or residual solvents from extraction. It does not confirm the species. Those need their own lines on the COA, with their own methods.
It also does not make any statement about effects on the people who take your product. This post is about measurement, not about health outcomes, and we make no claims about the latter.
The short version
- Specify lion’s mane by β-glucan measured with an enzymatic method, reported alongside total glucan and α-glucan.
- Treat “polysaccharides” by phenol-sulfuric acid as a different, broader measurement that cannot support a β-glucan claim on its own.
- Check the lab’s accreditation scope for the glucan test.
- Ask for three lots, not one.
Our lion’s mane program sets out the full list of documents we request and the red flags we look for. If you already have a supplier’s COA in hand, send it for a free 24-hour flag check: we reply with the top 2 red flags we see.
Footnotes
-
McCleary BV, Draga A. Measurement of β-glucan in mushrooms and mycelial products. Journal of AOAC International. 2016;99(2):364–373. doi:10.5740/jaoacint.15-0289. https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26957216/ ↩ ↩2 ↩3
-
DuBois M, Gilles KA, Hamilton JK, Rebers PA, Smith F. Colorimetric method for determination of sugars and related substances. Analytical Chemistry. 1956;28(3):350–356. https://doi.org/10.1021/ac60111a017 ↩
-
ISO/IEC 17025:2017, General requirements for the competence of testing and calibration laboratories. https://www.iso.org/standard/66912.html ↩
Common questions
Is 30% polysaccharides the same as 30% beta-glucan?
No. “Polysaccharides” measured by the phenol-sulfuric acid method counts sugars in general, including starch and added maltodextrin. Beta-glucan measured enzymatically counts only the fungal glucans.
Which test should I ask for on lion’s mane extract?
An enzymatic beta-glucan test, reported with total glucan and alpha-glucan, so you can see how much of the material is starch.
Why does mycelium on grain matter?
Mycelium grown on grain carries the grain’s starch into the extract. A polysaccharide figure can look high while the beta-glucan content is low.
How many lots should I check?
Ask for COAs from three production lots. One good lot does not show that the supplier is consistent.
- lion’s mane
- beta-glucan
- methods
- mushroom extracts